Question 385 - The Enlightening Answer Across the Ether, Vol 4

Supporters Response:

In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful. Praise be to Allah, Lord of the worlds, and may Allah send His prayers upon Muhammad and his family, the Imams and the Mahdis, and grant them abundant peace. First: No filmed video of Sayyed Ahmed Alhasan exists at all, so you are mistaken, brother. Second: Are you one of the Shia scholars? Are you among those whose names Sayyed Ahmed Alhasan (a) mentioned? Have you examined the proofs of the blessed Yamani call? Do you know the circumstances surrounding the request for debate? Many other questions could be raised regarding your strange request, because you are not among those addressed by the request for debate. The proof is that you lack the most important characteristic of a researcher-let alone of a scholar-which is investigating and studying the call's proofs and sources. How can you request a debate when you do not possess the qualifications of a beginning researcher? Do you detect even a trace of wisdom in this request of yours? Noble brother, if you seek the truth and are sincere in supporting Imam al-Mahdi (a), then you must be serious about researching and investigating. It has been narrated from the truthful ones (a), according to its meaning: ‘Ask about your religion until it is said of you that you are mad.’ Brother, you have not even put yourself to the trouble of reading one book among the Yamani call's publications written by the Supporter brothers, let alone those traced by the pure hand of the Yamani (a). Let us see your replies and observations concerning what the Supporters have written and the extent of your knowledge, so that you might then leap to requesting a debate. Since advice is a right and duty between believers, I advise you, brother, to seriously investigate what the Yamani call presents today. You must examine its proofs, what it calls to, what it relies upon, and what its arguments and demonstrations are. If you manage to do that, we ask Allah, Glorious is He, to decree for you guidance to the path of truth, spare you the need to request a debate, and remove from your shoulders what you have burdened yourself with although Allah, Glorious is He, did not charge you with it. Praise be to Allah alone, alone, alone. The Scientific Committee Supporters of Imam al-Mahdi (may Allah establish him upon the earth) Mr. Zaki al-Ansari 15 Ramadan 1430 AH