A source-grounded referenceReading guide

Meaning of Mutanaffil in the Rules of Congregational Prayer — Jurisprudential Answers — Book of Prayer

From WikiSavior, a source-grounded reference

Prayermutanaffil congregational prayer · repeat obligatory prayer congregation · congregational prayer · nafilah · obligatory prayer · repetition
Topic: PrayerCite this page

published translation

Contents
  1. Question and answer
  2. See also
  3. More in Prayer
  4. References
  5. Editorial notes

Question and answer [link]

Question 140

Al-Shara'i states that congregational prayer is not valid for supererogatory prayers except the prayer for rain and the two Eid prayers when the conditions of obligation are not met. What, then, is meant by the statement elsewhere that a person performing a 'supererogatory' prayer may follow one performing an obligatory prayer, and that a person performing an obligatory prayer may in some cases follow one performing a 'supererogatory' prayer?

Ahmed al-Hasan Response:

The person described here as performing a 'supererogatory' prayer is not someone performing a nafilah prayer, but someone repeating an obligatory prayer. This is explained by the statement immediately following it in al-Shara'i: 'It is recommended for a person who prayed alone to repeat the prayer if the person finds others performing that prayer in congregation, whether as imam or follower.'

published translation. Source [1]

Source: الأجوبة الفقهية (كتاب الصلاة); Question 140; Page 33; FIQH-PRAYER-Q140. View Arabic source · Open the original Arabic source ↗

View Arabic source

See also

More in Prayer

Browse all Prayer questions

References

  1. ↑ السيد أحمد الحسن. الأجوبة الفقهية (كتاب الصلاة). Question 140; Page 33. FIQH-PRAYER-Q140. View Arabic source
Cite this page

الأجوبة الفقهية (كتاب الصلاة) — السيد أحمد الحسن. Question: 140. Page: 33. FIQH-PRAYER-Q140. https://books.ahmadalhassan.com/readbookshow/149

Changing the interface language does not translate or approve a ruling.

Editorial notes

The page title and topic labels are WikiSavior editorial wording, not quotations from the author.

Changing the interface language does not translate or approve a ruling.

View source · Page information
{
  "id": "FIQH-PRAYER-Q140",
  "book_title_ar": "الأجوبة الفقهية (كتاب الصلاة)",
  "author": "السيد أحمد الحسن",
  "question_number": 140,
  "page_number": 33,
  "source_url": "https://books.ahmadalhassan.com/readbookshow/149",
  "source_language": "ar"
}
Subjects: Prayer · Source library